Blog

Our best product audit this year was AI slop

17 Nov 2026

Last week a pre-sales enquiry arrived by email — a list of questions about our software. They’re a normal thing to get and I’ve answered plenty, so I hit reply and started answering. It didn’t end. Eventually I scrolled to see what I was dealing with: 99 questions in 11 numbered sections.

Every question was exactly one sentence long, in the same even register, and every section was built the same way. A human asked to write 99 questions gets bored before they start, and boredom widens things: the questionnaire quickly collapses into a handful of “how does it handle X” items. This one never got bored and never collapsed anything.

So yes, that was AI slop. Ninety-nine generated questions, waiting for me to answer them.

A few times I thought about pasting the whole thing into a model and letting it write the reply. Fair, in a way I found hard to argue with: if their machine was going to read my answers, mine could write them. I didn’t.

I kept going, and eventually it stopped feeling like a sales form. Creep, gutters, mixed page sizes, bleed, crop marks — the details that decide whether imposition software survives a real job.

Halfway through I started using it as a checklist, and it was better than ours.

Once I’d finished, I went back and counted how many I’d said yes to. 91 out of 99. The eight that didn’t were all in two places: large-format roll work and vehicle wraps, which isn’t our market, and nesting and ganging, which we don’t do yet and should. Both are where the gaps ought to be. It was a fair test, and we did well on it.

Two feelings, though. One is that support just got harder, with a machine on the other side producing questions for free. The other is that our best product audit this year was written by a robot that will never know how well it did.

So what do we do the next time one of these arrives? Make a page with all the answers and reply with a “feed your AI” link? Answer by hand and keep score? Let our model sell to their model and step out of the way entirely?

I don’t know. I’d make the page, but answering with a link feels wrong.

P.S. They never replied.